Xtreme Regret is a Carolina Reaper hot sauce that earns its name — the instant-regret heat without losing the flavor.

Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce hits an estimated ~800,000 SHU* from a 50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion. This is a serious carolina reaper sauce — fiery and pepper-forward — that has earned 9 awards for balancing extreme heat with real flavor. Reach for it when "instant regret" is exactly the experience you want.

Flavor & Heat Profile

Heat / Scoville: An estimated ~800,000 SHU* — extreme
Peppers: 50% blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion
Taste: Bold, pepper-forward heat with lasting burn and real flavor
Size: 5 fl oz bottle

How to Use It

Add Xtreme Regret a few drops at a time to wings, tacos, chili, ramen, or eggs when you want genuine instant-regret heat. As a Carolina Reaper hot sauce built on a real pepper blend, it brings flavor along with the fire — but treat an estimated ~800,000 SHU* with respect and build up slowly.

Why You'll Love It

True Carolina Reaper hot sauce at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*
50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion
9x award winner for heat and flavor
Instant-regret heat that still tastes like peppers, not extract
Non-GMO, gluten-free, and vegan
Nut-free, soy-free, and dairy-free
From a 63x award-winning brand

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Xtreme Regret Scoville rating? How hot is it?

Xtreme Regret comes in at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*, powered by a 50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion. That makes this carolina reaper hot sauce genuinely extreme — true instant-regret territory — while keeping the bold pepper flavor that extract-based sauces lack. Start with one or two drops.

Is Xtreme Regret a real Carolina Reaper sauce?

Yes. Xtreme Regret is built on a 50% pepper blend featuring Carolina Reaper alongside Trinidad Scorpion, so it is a true carolina reaper sauce rather than a flavored extract. The result is an estimated ~800,000 SHU* of bold, pepper-forward heat that has earned 9 awards for balancing fire with flavor.

Why is it called instant regret hot sauce?

The name fits the experience: at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*, Xtreme Regret delivers fast, intense Carolina Reaper heat that lingers. It is the kind of instant regret hot sauce chiliheads chase — but because it is a real 50% pepper blend, the regret comes with genuine flavor, not just punishment.

*SHU is estimated based on the percentage of peppers used.

Filter and sort

Filter

Products

67 products

Sort by:

Stubb's® Sticky Sweet Barbecue Sauce

TILLEN FARMS: Merry Maraschino Cherries Pitted and Stem On, 13.5 oz

Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce

Yellowbird Classic Jalapeño Hot Sauce